Home    Song Critiques    Song Plugging    Song coaching/rewrite consulting    The Truth    Song Demos    Number Charts   Rates    About us    Contact
Song Critiques/Evaluations/Publishing
Submission Guidelines

Submitting songs for us to critique is now easier than ever.  You are no longer required to request permission to submit material.  Our rates have changed for song critiques. They are now $20.00 per song. You won't be disappointed.   You may pay by Credit Card or PayPal!  All songs submitted to us for critique are automatically considered for publishing.  Yes, we DO accept "lyric only" submissions.

1.  Click the yellow button to purchase your Write THIS Music Song Critique:



Song Critique Options
2.  After you purchase your critique, click HERE to Email us your song mp3 and lyrics.
 

We evaluate songs in groups and you may not hear back within 24 hours.  It may take a bit longer if we're slammed.  Bug us if you don't hear back within a week or so.  We don't mind.  If you order more than 1 please allow some extra time for each additional song.

We only accept song submissions by email (although there are some exceptions made for non-U.S. writers) and we do not go to websites to critique songs that have been posted.

What to Expect from your Song Evaluations

What you'll get from us is information you can use.  We do not consider comments like "Your song is not commercial enough" or "Your song isn't what the market is looking for" to be useful information.  Song publishers (or music publishers) don't always have the time, or perhaps the desire, to give constructive criticism.  While the above 2 comments may be actually be true for a song comments like these are useless to the writer and you won't hear them from us.  Instead you'll hear what the songs strong points are as well as specific reasons why a song might be a tough pitch on Music Row.  If you'd like, we'll also tell you how to fix it.  Read on...

If we think your song could be a possible contender following a good rewrite, we'll offer you a rewrite consult.  This offer is made on about 1 or 2 out of every 10 songs submitted.  We do not offer Rewrite Consults on every song we receive by any stretch...only those possessing market potential.

We give honest, straightforward, constructive criticism and feedback.  If that's what you want, then you've come to the right place. We won't pull punches to earn your business. And that's a promise.

We're looking for writers who can not only handle criticism, but also use it to improve their craft.  Criticism isn't about a writer's character, talent, personal value, or potential and it shouldn't be taken as such. It's about the song, period. If you are unable to accept criticism and use it toward your skill development as a songwriter, you may be in the wrong business.
"I think your evaluation was awesome, br.... You obviously poured yourself into looking at this particular song. I find much food for thought and clear perspective in what you've shared. This seems to be something you're very good at." C. Evan Loenard,  Anderson, SC

"I got a response from Harlan Howard Songs...my contact in Nashville. Well, you surely do have the ear! [They] said basically exactly what you said!" Orlando Luckey, Cincinnati OH.

"Thank you so much for taking the time in giving intelligent critiques.  You make perfect sense, and at least you didn't tell me that I should take up knitting. Thanks for all you do for us nobody songwriters"  Brenda McBryde, San Antonio, TX

"First, let me tell you that you're great!  I truly appreciate the way you express things: it's clear and always documented with a reason or an example.  I'll tell the people around me that you know how to evaluate a song, because you do.  You know your business and it shows.  Let me tell you that you've taught me a lot of things in a few lines.  I won't forget your kindness and professionalism..."   Yann Couseret, Castellane,  France